"It's in the Water!"
New York style Pizza made with water from our exclusive water system!
About Us
About Our Pizzeria
Charlie, born in Brooklyn, New York and later raised in Queens and his wife, Shannon born and raised in Virginia both grew up in the restaurant world. His parents have owned restaurants in Queens, New York for over 40 years, while Shannon's grandparents owned a cafeteria in Portsmouth for over 20 years. Charlie and Shannon both attribute their restaurant upbringing with their love and passion for culinary and serving others. After leaving New York and starting a family in Virginia Beach, Charlie noticed the lack of New York style cuisines. He wanted to bring that New York Style cuisine to Virginia Beach to share it with the community and give his family the experience he had growing up. Now you can find our New York style "mom and pop" pizzeria in the Red Mill Commons shopping center! Stop in and grab a slice from one of our delicious New York pies!
New York Water Maker
New York Water Maker designed and created the famous filtration system that has been feature in Forbes magazine. This exclusive filtration system removes the hard impurities found in our local city water, and is designed to replicate the New York water which flows straight from the Catskills mountain. The system provides Brooklyn Pizzeria with the key ingredient to making a good pizza. Every true New Yorker knows "it's in the water".
Menu / Price List
18" Pizza
White with spinach and Garlic
22
Ricotta, garlic, fresh spinach, Parmesan, and Mozzarella
Cheese
17
Sicilian
20
Fresh Mozzarella topped with tomato sauce
Sicilican Sfincione
23
Aged Provolone and roasted tomatoes
Margherita
23
Fresh Mozzarella, Plum tomato, garlic
Hawaiian
22
Pineapple, ham, Mozzarella, tomato sauce
Grilled Veggie Special
22
Grilled fresh vegetables, extra Mozzarella, light tomato sauce
Brooklyn Style
24
Pepperoni, sausage, onion, mushroom, red peppers , extra cheese
Meat Lovers
24
Extra cheese, Pepperoni, Sausage, meatball, ham, and bacon
Spicy Buffalo Chicken
21
Chicken, Buffalo sauce, and cheese
Stuffed Pizza
29
Additional Toppings
2.50
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, pepperoncini, olive, onion, peppers, mushrooms, pineapple, Bacon
Specialty Toppings
3.50
Spinach, red onion, Feta cheese, Chicken, Kalamata olive, Fresh Mozzarella